Do They Know It's Christmas?
This BBC story about the fading English tradition of the nativity play caught my eye. Actually, England might be a bit behind the curve if their authorities are trying to deracinate their children by going to the trouble of entirely banning Christmas. This side of the Atlantic, the preferred tactic is to submerge the holiday in a sea of allegedly analogous festivals of other cultures. A friend was telling me that her kid's class has to celebrate the "season of festivals" by "doing presentations" on such vital December traditions as a Korean Doll Festival (the one her unlucky son had drawn from the gender-neutral hat)...in addition, no doubt, to Hannukah, Kwanzaa, etc. etc. and, somewhere down the list, the quaint story of a boy born in Bethlehem. So Christmas is not "banned" at all--how could anyone say that? Au contraire, my hysterical rightwing friends your Yule holiday is still very much in the picture, in much the same sense that "Where's Waldo" is.
A propos of my title, could it be that the battered old holiday needs a benefit concert of its own? "Banned Aid", maybe. Hmm...on second thought, maybe it's better to let the West die with dignity than to allow ourselves to be assaulted again by the versification of its latter-day poets, e.g.:
But say a prayer. Pray for the other ones
At Christmastime it's hard
But when you're having fun
There's a world outside your window
And it's a world of dread and fear
Where the only water flowing is the bitter sting* of tears.
*I guess this was meant to be "sting" with a lower-case "s" even though I think it was actually being sung by the upper-case, and possibly bitter, and wet, "Sting".
6 comments:
i say merry christmas, not least to this 'culture war,' which spent this year of our lord 2005 happily calcifying.
(i'm pretty much the 'MSM' though i guess, so who knows?)
1. Yes you are very, very mainstream, unlike countercultural me.
2. I admit this blog post is maybe a year late, or more, since everyone seems to be caving on the Christmas stuff. However I didn't have a blog last year and so am reduced to fighting its battles now.
3. I'm not so brave as to say "Merry Christmas" much myself, of course, although I would of course say it to you and will when the time is right.
Re: 'Hmm...on second thought, maybe it's better to let the West die with dignity.'
Note: The West =| Christianity.
The West has never been better. Christianity is withering away. The Enlightenment project moves forward. More Freedom and Reason lie ahead!
You're right "a crazier," the west does not equal Christianity...it equals the descendants of European Christendom.
'A crazier'? lol
So does Classical civilisation count as part of the 'West'? I should think that Homer, Socrates, Plato, Aristotle, Epicurus, the Stoics, Sextus Empiricus, Cicero, et al. are all important figures of Western civilisation.
Yet, none of them were Christians.
What about the Enlightenment? I'd be hard pressed to think of more important figures who contributed to the West's development than Hobbes, Diderot, Voltaire, Rousseau, Hume, Smith, Jefferson, Madison, Franklin, Bentham, Mill, et al.
Yet, none of them were Christians.
The notion that the West was defined, at any time in its history, exclusively by 'Christianity' is absurd.
Also, speaking of Chrismas, what we celebrate at this time of year is actually a Roman holiday called 'Saturnalia'. Christ was born in October. But the pagan holiday Saturnalia was substituted because it was a popular holiday in the Roman Empire (it involved the exchange of gifts). The fact that we celebrate Christmas at this time of the year is the result of a crass 'PR move'.
Marketing with respect to Christmas is not new!
The notion that the West was defined, at any time in its history, exclusively by 'Christianity' is absurd.
Well maybe not quite so absurd for the very long period between the two periods you mention.
But I take your points. It was never my intention to argue that the West is by definition uniformly "Christian" where that is taken to refer to an active belief in the religious centrality of the teachings and example of Jesus Christ.
Post a Comment